Amateur Chess Magazine, 1872

S:
i. 1 (June 1872), p. 10-11: prizes 1-9
i. 3 (Aug. 1872), p. 36: prizes 16-19, awards 1-9
i. 4 (Sep. 1872), p. 39; 48: prizes 25-26; prizes 20-24, awards 10-15
Oct. 1872, p. 60: prizes 27-34, awards 16-19
Nov. 1872, p. 66: prizes 35-40, awards 20-26
 
(As the cited source does not retain issue covers, issue numbers have been taken from the awards listings. The volume was going to end with i. 7.)
 
N:

Amateur Chess Magazine was issued between July and November, 1872, as far as known. In each issue the editor offered prizes for chess problems, solutions to problems, getting new members, ladies' contributions, etc. While not tourneys in the usual format, they may nevertheless be cited as such.

The following prizes were directly related to chess compositions (boldface indicates that the prize was awarded):

1. Best set of three original problems
2. Best set of two original problems
3. Best self-mate

10. Best set of three original problems

17. Best set of three original problems

21. Best set of six original problems
22. Best set of three original problems
23. Best end game

28. Best set of six original chess problems
29. Best set of three original chess problems
30. Best original self-mate
31. Best original end game
32. Best original problem in 1 move
34. Best problem composer in v. 1.

36. Best set of six original chess problems.
37. Best set of three original chess problems.
38. Best problem in half-a-move.

The following awards were given:

1. F. C. Collins
2. H. E. Heather
3. F. W. Lord

17. F. C. Collins

22. W. C. Cotton
23. R. W. Johnson.

The awards do not identify the relevant problems or end-games, and any published problems (F. C. Collins and W. C. Cotton only; none of the published problems by F. W. Lord is a self-mate) do not refer to any awards.

In the October issue, a short notice appears that "Mr. Collins' problems will appear next month", and in November three retractor problems appear, under his name and the epigraph: Second thoughts are best. (See Amateur Chess Magazine, Nov. 1872, p. 62.) Unfortunately it is not stated positively that they were awarded a prize.

A prize that is somewhat related to chess problems was also offered:

24. most ridiculous chess motto

but, again, an award would have been expected in the December issue, which, if it was published, has not been preserved.

In addition to these, prizes 9, 15, and 19 were for the best contribution by a lady. While this covers chess problems, it may also cover solutions and other material. Only one was awarded:

9. Best contribution by a lady

which was won by M. Rudge. As problems 17, 23 and 28 are by her, it is possible that this award was given for any of these problems, but it is not said so explicitly.

As none of the awards from Amateur Chess Magazine publish or refer to the problems that were given for, or clearly plan to do so, they can not really be regarded as full problem tourneys.