Sydney Mail, 1876
According to the title pages of the referenced issues, the full title
of the newspaper is
The Sydney Mail and New South Wales Advertiser.
45 problems were received.
Several persons were thanked for assisting the chess editor with
the awards, but
it is not clear if they acted as judges or only as advisers. The editor
appears to refer to them as judges, but the final report is not clearly
from their hands.
Additional mentions were given at the end of the judge's report
but are not included here as they appear to be more informal.
Some months after the prizes had been awarded, the editor noticed that
J. Willis's problem contained one or two rather important duals, and
wondered that no one (the author, the solving readers, or the judges) had
seen them earlier. He also said that as the award had been made, it could
not be altered, and that Henderson's problem (hm.) deserved something more
in terms of award. The award was therefore amended to give Henderson's #4
a special prize.
Prizes
Problems in 3 or 4 moves
Prize: J. Willis

#3
Problems in 2 moves
Prize: S. Tyrrell

#2
Amendment
Special Prize: T. Henderson

#4